KUALA LUMPUR | A former sales and marketing executive, described as a “serial vexatious litigant”, was ordered to pay her ex-employer RM3,000 in costs after the Industrial Court dismissed her claim of unfair dismissal from employment.
Court chairman D Paramalingam said the cost award issued against Ching Suet Yeen “was a deterrent not only to the claimant (Ching) but also to other litigants from filing multiple claims against their former employers in order to seek financial gain”.
“Thus, by the power vested under Regulation 5 of the Industrial Relations Regulations 1967, this court orders costs of RM3,000 against the claimant to be paid to the company’s solicitors, Messrs San & Co, within 30 days of this award,” he said.
In a written award handed down yesterday, Paramalingam said the Industrial Court does not usually make an award of costs, save “in exceptional cases where the conduct of the parties become questionable”.
He said the lawyers representing employer Lepcon Tools (M) Sdn Bhd had highlighted during the proceedings that Ching had brought at least 10 other unfair dismissal claims against her previous employers since 2010.
“This clearly shows that the claimant is a serial vexatious litigant and has a habit of bringing claims against her former employers,” said Paramalingam.
He said the court would be failing in its duty if it does not jealously guard judicial time and resources, especially since the Industrial Court does not normally impose cost orders.
“The modus operandi and the frequency in which the claimant had dragged her employers for unfair dismissal cases certainly shows a worrying trend where the Industrial Court might be seen to be more of a goldmine rather than a place to seek justice,” he added.
Paramalingam pointed out that Ching was absent when her case was called up for hearing in October last year.
He said it was evident from documents submitted by the employer that Ching had not only performed poorly but had been untruthful in her job application.
“Her disclosure that her previous employer between 2018 and 2022 was Shining Engineering Enterprise was false. She had never worked in the said Shining Engineering Enterprise throughout that period, but was in fact jumping from one company to another, totalling five companies,” Paramalingam said in his 33-page award.
Paramalingam found that Lepcon Tools was justified in terminating Ching’s employment.
“Despite the company giving the claimant a further opportunity by extending her probationary period after May 16, 2022, the claimant remained stubborn and refused to improve on her work performance and attitude. It would seem that the claimant was engineering a move to get herself sacked from her employment.”
The company had no alternative and was in fact justified in issuing her with a termination letter, Paramalingam said.
Lawyers Lee Yen Jia and San Peggy represented the company.
Source: Mohd Farhaan Shah. (2023, Dec 20). Immigration nabs Bangladesh national over fake work permit renewal syndicate. The Star. https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2023/12/20/immigration-nabs-bangladesh-national-over-fake-work-permit-renewal-syndicate#:~:text=Johor%20Immigration%20director%20Baharuddin%20Tahir,since%20early%20this%20year%20here.
- A furniture factory fail to adhere to Act 446
JASIN | In a recent integrated enforcement operation led by the state Labour Department (JTK), a furniture factory in Sungai Rambai has come under scrutiny for multiple violations, exposing the inadequate living conditions provided to its foreign workers. The factory owner now faces potential legal consequences for offenses that range from lacking proper accommodation certificates […] - Time to name and shame migrant worker abusers, say activists
PETALING JAYA | An activist has welcomed the suggestion for a royal commission of inquiry (RCI) into the migrant workers management system and forced labor problem, saying it would “name and shame” those responsible for migrant worker abuses. Adrian Pereira of North-South Initiative said setting up an RCI would mean having a more competent investigating […] - HR minister: 751 duped migrant workers file RM2m claim for unpaid wages
PUTRAJAYA | Human Resources Minister Steven Sim today said that the 751 foreign workers who were duped over non-existent jobs in Pengerang, Johor have filed a RM2.21 million claim. In a joint press conference with Home Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail at Kompleks Setia Perdana, today, he further shared that the claim was made […] - Malaysia’s Unemployment Drops to Pre-Pandemic Levels
KUALA LUMPUR | The unemployment rate for November 2023 is showing a decrease in number, dropping to 3.3 percent, with 569,000 jobless individuals—the same as pre-pandemic levels. This improvement from October’s 3.4 percent was reported in the latest Labour Force statistics by the Department of Statistics Malaysia (DOSM). Chief Statistician Datuk Seri Dr Mohd Uzir […] - RM50,000 fine if company docks wages during water cuts, says minister
BUTTERWORTH | Employers can be fined up to RM50,000 under the Employment Act 1955 if they dock their workers’ wages or force them to go on annual leave, should they opt to shutdown operations following the water supply disruption in Penang from Jan 10 to 14. Human resources minister Steven Sim said employers and employees can […] - Contractor licenses are misused to aid foreign worker syndicates, says source
PETALING JAYA | Company licenses are abused in various sectors, including construction, which is believed to be a tactic to bring in workers from source countries, especially Bangladesh. According to a source, certain groups were using valid contractor licenses issued by the Construction Industry Development Board (CIDB) to facilitate the recruitment of foreign workers for […] - MICSEA Commends MOHR for its Commitment to Enhancing Governance and Tackling Bribery Risk with the Adoption of ABMS Guide—PRESS STATEMENT
Kuala Lumpur, 8 January 2024 – The Malaysian Industrial Commercial and Service Employers Association (MICSEA) fully supports the Ministry of Human Resources (MOHR)’s decision to adopt the Anti-Bribery Management System (ABMS) guide in order to enhance governance and tackle bribery risk. As an organization committed to promoting ethical and transparent business practices, we believe that […] - MICSEA Supports Strict Action Against Employers Who Deceive Foreign Workers in Malaysia — PRESS STATEMENT
Kuala Lumpur, January 6, 2024 – The Malaysian Industrial Commercial and Service Employers Association (MICSEA) supports the decision of Home Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail and Human Resources Minister Steven Sim Chee Keong to take strict action against employers who deceive foreign workers into securing non-existent jobs in Pengerang, Johor. The joint statement issued […] - Industrial Court orders ‘vexatious litigant’ to pay ex-employer legal costs
KUALA LUMPUR | A former sales and marketing executive, described as a “serial vexatious litigant”, was ordered to pay her ex-employer RM3,000 in costs after the Industrial Court dismissed her claim of unfair dismissal from employment. Court chairman D Paramalingam said the cost award issued against Ching Suet Yeen “was a deterrent not only to […] - Adopting the Progressive Wage Model through a voluntary and pilot-based approach offers flexibility in implementation and the opportunity to refine the model for practicality and effectiveness – PRESS STATEMENT
Kuala Lumpur, December 2, 2023 – The Malaysian Industrial Commercial and Service Employers Association (MICSEA) expresses its gratitude to the Government for heeding the employers’ request to introduce the Progressive Wage Model (PWM) on a voluntary basis. This approach allows for flexible implementation, taking into consideration factors such as affordability, profitability, and industry competitiveness. The […]