KUALA LUMPUR | A former sales and marketing executive, described as a “serial vexatious litigant”, was ordered to pay her ex-employer RM3,000 in costs after the Industrial Court dismissed her claim of unfair dismissal from employment.
Court chairman D Paramalingam said the cost award issued against Ching Suet Yeen “was a deterrent not only to the claimant (Ching) but also to other litigants from filing multiple claims against their former employers in order to seek financial gain”.
“Thus, by the power vested under Regulation 5 of the Industrial Relations Regulations 1967, this court orders costs of RM3,000 against the claimant to be paid to the company’s solicitors, Messrs San & Co, within 30 days of this award,” he said.
In a written award handed down yesterday, Paramalingam said the Industrial Court does not usually make an award of costs, save “in exceptional cases where the conduct of the parties become questionable”.
He said the lawyers representing employer Lepcon Tools (M) Sdn Bhd had highlighted during the proceedings that Ching had brought at least 10 other unfair dismissal claims against her previous employers since 2010.
“This clearly shows that the claimant is a serial vexatious litigant and has a habit of bringing claims against her former employers,” said Paramalingam.
He said the court would be failing in its duty if it does not jealously guard judicial time and resources, especially since the Industrial Court does not normally impose cost orders.
“The modus operandi and the frequency in which the claimant had dragged her employers for unfair dismissal cases certainly shows a worrying trend where the Industrial Court might be seen to be more of a goldmine rather than a place to seek justice,” he added.
Paramalingam pointed out that Ching was absent when her case was called up for hearing in October last year.
He said it was evident from documents submitted by the employer that Ching had not only performed poorly but had been untruthful in her job application.
“Her disclosure that her previous employer between 2018 and 2022 was Shining Engineering Enterprise was false. She had never worked in the said Shining Engineering Enterprise throughout that period, but was in fact jumping from one company to another, totalling five companies,” Paramalingam said in his 33-page award.
Paramalingam found that Lepcon Tools was justified in terminating Ching’s employment.
“Despite the company giving the claimant a further opportunity by extending her probationary period after May 16, 2022, the claimant remained stubborn and refused to improve on her work performance and attitude. It would seem that the claimant was engineering a move to get herself sacked from her employment.”
The company had no alternative and was in fact justified in issuing her with a termination letter, Paramalingam said.
Lawyers Lee Yen Jia and San Peggy represented the company.
Source: Mohd Farhaan Shah. (2023, Dec 20). Immigration nabs Bangladesh national over fake work permit renewal syndicate. The Star. https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2023/12/20/immigration-nabs-bangladesh-national-over-fake-work-permit-renewal-syndicate#:~:text=Johor%20Immigration%20director%20Baharuddin%20Tahir,since%20early%20this%20year%20here.
- STEVEN SIM: MALAYSIA OPENS NATIONAL TRAINING WEEK TO ALL ASEAN CITIZENS FOR THE FIRST TIME
KUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia, May 27, 2025 /PRNewswire/ — In a landmark move under its ASEAN Chairmanship, Malaysia will open its flagship National Training Week (NTW) to all ASEAN citizens for the first time, offering over 65,000 free training opportunities across the country and online from 14-21 June 2025. The Honourable Mr Steven Sim Chee Keong, Minister of […] - Steven Sim: One-stop labour centre to be expanded nationwide by year end
KEPALA BATAS (Sept 6): The Ministry of Human Resources’ (Kesuma) one-stop labour centre, which consolidates all the ministry’s key services under one roof, is set to be expanded nationwide by the end of this year. Human Resources Minister Steven Sim said that the one-stop centre aims to streamline service delivery for employees, employers, and unions, […] - SMEs sound alarm on rising costs and red tape despite cautious optimism
MALAYSIA’S small and medium enterprises (SMEs), the backbone of the economy, are entering the second half of 2025 (2H25) under mounting pressure from rising costs, regulatory burdens and labour shortages, even as many remain cautiously optimistic about growth prospects. In separate statements last week, the Malaysian Industrial, Commercial and Service Employers Association (MICSEA) and the Small […] - From worry to strategy
FROM drafting documents to analysing performance, generative artificial intelligence (AI) is beginning to shape how bosses and employees interact. For many companies, this means rethinking old rules and practices to keep things fair, transparent and legally sound. To get ahead of this shift, the Malaysian Industrial, Commercial and Services Employers Associa-tion (MICSEA) has begun initiatives […] - Malaysia rises eight sport to 25th in IMD Talent Ranking
PUTRAJAYA: Malaysia has jumped eight spots to 25th position in the IMD World Talent Ranking 2025, reflecting the country’s growing ability to become one of the key destinations for global professionals. Human Resources Minister Steven Sim said that in the Asia-Pacific region, Malaysia is ranked fifth, after Hong Kong, Singapore, Taiwan and Australia. He said […] - Human Resources Ministry opens two probes into Johor bus company following driver strike over salary cuts and excessive overtime
PUTRAJAYA, July 22 — The Ministry of Human Resources (KESUMA) has opened two investigation papers against a transport company following a bus driver strike at the Sultan Iskandar Building (BSI) in Johor Bahru on Sunday. In a statement today, the ministry said that initial findings by the Department of Labour Peninsular Malaysia (JTKSM) have found […] - Malaysia enacts flexible working arrangements for employees
Employees in Malaysia can now formally request flexible work arrangements from their employers, according to an announcement by Steven Sim, Malaysia’s Minister of Human Resources. Sim, utilising social media platform X, clarified that employees have the right to apply for variations in work hours, days, and location under Sections 60P and 60Q of the Employment […] - Gig workers to get financial literacy boost under HR Ministry initiative
BUKIT MERTAJAM, Sept 22 — The Human Resources Ministry (Kesuma) is planning to introduce a financial management course for gig workers as part of efforts to help them plan their finances more effectively and empower the group. “During the programme, some expressed anxiety about paying taxes, which points to a lack of understanding of taxation […] - Loke says uniting Penang DAP to be Steven Sim’s biggest political test
KUALA LUMPUR, April 19 — DAP secretary-general Anthony Loke said Steven Sim’s new role in the party’s central leadership is not a demotion but a political challenge tied to Penang’s future. Sim now holds the post of deputy secretary-general while also serving as Penang DAP chief and human resources minister. In a Malaysiakini podcast, Loke painted the […] - DPM Fadillah: SMEs must invest in talent to drive growth, stay competitive
PUTRAJAYA, Sept 8 — Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Fadillah Yusof today reminded small and medium enterprises (SMEs) that while the government is committed to providing policies and incentives that support growth and human capital development, real transformation must begin within each organisation. Fadillah, who is also energy transition and water transformation minister, said leaders […]